Posts by Bart Janssen
Last ←Newer Page 1 2 3 4 5 Older→ First
-
Hard News: The Vision Thing, in reply to
A PhD scientist with 8-9 years training starts at a CRI at about 50k and can expect to get up to about 80k after 20 years.
Engineers get more in some industries abut not in others.
I'm sorry Kier I just simply disagree with you that the "market" will sort it out. Call it an ideological difference.
We exist in an essentially market driven environment now and the numbers of student willing to do science is steadily dropping. What's worse is the quality is dropping too. When you look to see where those really bright stage I students went, they went to one of the high paid professions.
-
Hard News: The Vision Thing, in reply to
Bollocks.
We pay lawyers many times what we pay engineers. Smart kids choose a profession where they get their loans back fast
-
Hard News: The Vision Thing, in reply to
None taken.
The word was encourage. Not all will choose that path. But at present it seems we discourage the best and brightest from choosing that path and instead channel them to law and commerce. We need some of those just not as many as we train now.
If your comment was meant to imply I lack an appreciation of the other fields taught at University, in particular the humanities, then you are mistaken.
-
Read the speech twice now and left with the impression that it is a decent start.
It really will be important to see the detail.
Stuff like enabling education professionals to make decisions about what is best rather than politicians.
Like an appropriate role for tech institutes, tech trainees are as valuable to society as lawyers.
Like appropriate management of universities to encourage the training of the kinds of skill we need not simply those that make money, yes that's social engineering but that is the point.
And yes if you want the encourage the brightest to become scientists and engineers who can innovate a new economy you must fund them on excellence not some moronic treasury bullet point.
-
Hard News: The Vision Thing, in reply to
if none of his senior specialists were paid more than him
Basically he's saying that if he has hired well, then his specialist are more knowledgable and capable in their area than him and hence deserving of more salary.
It also acknowledges that in many cases there are few people with the specialist skills whereas there are many people with the managerial skills.
The only point about that I'd argue with is that really good managers are much rarer than the job titles would have you believe.
-
From the speech
Right now, they're following the money, and that means we're turning out an army of accountants.
Engineers and scientists, not so much.
Just a note we are now in the process of firing scientists from our CRIs while the accountants and management get pay rises.
The damage done to our research institutes will take decade to recover from.
And BTW that damage was started by Labour when they abandoned science funding to the control of treasury.
At present, I would not advise any child to become a scientist in New Zealand - that shocks and horrifies me.
-
Hard News: The Vision Thing, in reply to
the Nats are going to ram repugnant-to-most-voters actions through asap -this year and next so they can pork-barrel their way through their last year of this term.
This is standard for every government I have seen in NZ Labour or National led. Year 1 pass obnoxious vote losing legislation.
Year 2 make cuts to pad current account surplus
Year 3 spend that money on populist vote getting changesGet re-elected because nobody remembers the ugly year 1 stuff
-
Up Front: Safety Net, in reply to
I’ll go back to rewriting my tax course now….
I am deeply sorry for causing you to have to go back to writing such a document.
-
Up Front: Safety Net, in reply to
“I think your idea is silly” and “I think you are silly”
I'll make the point I made earlier. Mostly because it's a point I have taken so very long to understand myself.
There are people for whom having their ideas described as silly is a much worse insult than having their person described as silly. There are times where it is a much more certain way to end the prospect of conversation than you might expect.
Which basically leads to the conclusion that sometimes you just can't do or say anything right :).
-
Up Front: Safety Net, in reply to
all for telling men they’re being
I'm all for telling people...
I'm also all for being told ...
I know full well I can get patronising/lecturing/domineering, especially when I think I have something important to say.
Having folks around who can tell you to pull your head in is helpful.