Hard News: Thatcher
229 Responses
First ←Older Page 1 2 3 4 5 … 10 Newer→ Last
-
That is ,for someone from the left, a fair summing up of the Lady
Some people seem to have forgotten what a basket case the UK was then
I am sure it could have been do better but it had to be done -
here's my play list for the day:
-
In other countries, New Zealand included, the move to a new era of production was achieved pragmatically
What.
(On edit: I need an explicit definition of "pragmatically" to make any sense of this claim).
-
and of course there's: http://www.isthatcherdeadyet.co.uk/
Iain Banks is quoted:
"It's not over; we live with her legacy still (in the glorification of greed, the denigration of the idea of public service and the privatisation of financial return along with the nationalisation of debt we have just seen in our financial systems, apart from anything else). Margaret Thatcher did everything in her very considerable power to make greed fashionable and turn naked selfishness from a vice into a virtue, and I find that beyond unforgivable. It is partly due to her that we live in a world divided into the super-rich and everybody else, with the poor, the starving and the exploited of the world scrabbling for the crumbs of a civilization that values money beyond everything else. I fully intend to piss on her grave (no matter how long the queue) and believe me she's still getting off lightly."Hurry up, get her in the ground, the clock is ticking on that
and of course people are celebrating
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2013/apr/08/margaret-thatcher-death-party-brixton-glasgow -
Oh yes and there's CNN's goof today:
http://i1.cdnds.net/13/15/618x464/odd_thatcher_twitter.jpg
(collecting for the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children)
they both screwed miners
-
Russell Brown, in reply to
In other countries, New Zealand included, the move to a new era of production was achieved pragmatically
What.
In newspapers, it absolutely was. When I started at the Christchurch Star in 1981, they’d just gone through the change, retiring the old compositional technology in favour of a computer-based system. In consultation with the trade unions involved, workers were retrained and the large majority kept their jobs. It took years for the changes to fully play out, but there was a general recognition that this was the sensible way forward.
That didn’t happen in Britain. When I went to work there in 1986, I couldn’t believe how primitive things were. As The Guardian’s Alan Rusbridger has noted, his newspaper owes a debt to Murdoch for breaking the union lock on the way newspapers could be produced.
-
Glenn Pearce, in reply to
No Bragg ?
-
Stephen Judd, in reply to
In newspapers, it absolutely was.
Ok, I didn't read that sentence as confined to newspapers.
I was thinking of NZ's transformation in the 80s, along the same lines as the UKs, and having trouble understanding how that could be described as pragmatic.
Raymond says;
I am sure it could have been do better but it had to be done
This implies that what was done was fundamentally right, and flawed only in execution. I disagree. Something needed to be done, to be sure, but this is just recycling the myth that There Is (was) No Alternative.
-
Emma Hart, in reply to
No Bragg ?
I know what you mean, the 80s for me was largely sitting in freezing student flats listening to Bragg, but here's what he has to say today.
"This is not a time for celebration. This is a salient reminder of how Britain got into the mess that we are in today."
Mitch Benn has described living in Scotland under Thatcher as like living under a foreign occupation. That Thatcher's legacy is what's happening in Britain right now: the feeling that, if you are of a certain 'class', your own government despises you. How else would any government come up with something like the bedroom tax?
-
I actually searched for a Bragg I didn't find a BB that really called to me but here you are:
and to me the Beat's:
I said I see no joy
I see only sorry
I see no chance of your bright new tomorrow
So stand down Margaret
Stand down please
Stand down Margaretis what I think of when I think of Thatcher
-
I worked summers as a student in a hot type press shop as they were changing - it used to be that every word was read by 4 people before it hit the press - reporter->lino operator->copy holder->reader - every town had jobs for grammar nazis after they had gotten their english degrees - now it's a reporter and a spell checker and no one to really check the grammar .
Luckily they had a good union here in NZ - and while they could see the writing on the wall they negotiated the jobs away slowly
-
Of course, I've spent all morning grateful for the way my friends and my feeds have been talking about and demonstrating compassion, and what's running through my head? This:
-
Born in 1978 in the west coast of Scotland I had my milk snatched, protested the poll tax and watched the then shipyards shoved into unprofitability by the monetarist policies.
Towns such as mine became purposelessness and without the hard working balancing out the always present hard drinking, the social effects of the changes were apalling. It wasn't some workers paradise by any stretch of imagination, but the changes managed to turn Pride of the Clyde into the kind of place Ken Loach makes films about.
Fully agree with Emma/Mitch Benn's comments above, suspect it is why devolution was something to be feared by westminster then similarly with the current administration.
Me, I'm now just a bit freaked out by the comment from the mayor of hamilton:
juliehardakerNZ9:26am
Sad to hear of Margaret Thatcher's passing. A leader who will go down in history for her strength and resolve to bring change.Change at all costs.
-
Ian Dalziel, in reply to
Iain Banks
well at least he saw Maggie out...
..."... it looks like my latest novel,
The Quarry, will be my last." -
Ian: well that's why I said "Hurry up, get her in the ground, the clock is ticking on that"
-
I can't help wondering whether NZ would have endured the same degree of fervour from the Rogernomes if they hadn't had Thatcherism as a beacon. Yes some change was necessary, but the manner of the flogging-off of state assets has had some exceptionally negative consequences for NZ as a whole. We also saw the NZ Labour Party, in the same way as its UK namesake, embrace the market wholeheartedly; and fuck the working-class prolles.
-
Great analysis of Thatcher's very dubious legacy in The Quietus here
-
Hebe,
I have never again experienced the bleak, pervasive sense of alienation she fostered in government.
Exactly. I worked in London 1985-90 in the MSM and in the agitprop industry. That woman was and is anathema to me. I have not a good word to say about her and her government; their policies and the awful, awful carnage inflicted on individuals and society under her ideological jackboot. Rob Muldoon was a eccentric old uncle in comparison -- and he had a sense of humour. Thatcher and her people had none; a clear sign of fanaticism and stupidity.
-
I was living there at the time too. It was apparent that having crippled the union movement Thatcher was going after the Left's remaining power base in the councils. The poll tax was pure insanity, so egregiously inequitable it boggles the mind that anyone beyond a fox-hunting Tory peer would have given it the time of day. But she wanted to see the utter destruction of socialism, to have that as part of her legacy. It overrode every sensible consideration. That was her mode of governing, increasingly unrestrained as she went on. Just like Muldoon really.
-
Best thing about Thatcher: she unified people against her and insane policies like the poll tax. Worst thing? People focused on her personally, and ended up doing sweet fuck all in the end.
-
What is most difficult is people telling us that we should show 'respect' or 'compassion'. No, that is not needed nor justified; it should be kept for those people who lives were ruined by Thatcherism...and the hideous legacy she has bequeathed to us all,
-
I think it's perfectly acceptable to show the exact same level of respect and compassion that Mrs Thatcher had for society.
-
Bart Janssen, in reply to
Margaret Thatcher did everything in her very considerable power to make greed fashionable and turn naked selfishness from a vice into a virtue
It is no coincidence that the 1987 financial collapse happened after those policies of greed.
-
I grew up in the UK in the Thatcher years. She snatched my milk as a schoolchild, but her election as prime minister in 1979 probably saved my high school education, so I think that's a draw.
After that, though! My enduring memories of those years are:
Thatcher using the gift of the Falklands conflict to inspire jingoistic support. She then used this to enact a mass of extreme policies with no effective parliamentary opposition. A 'glorious' patriotic war enabled her to convince many working class people to be complicit in undermining their own futures.
Pre-Thatcher, my memory was that the homeless were largely middle-aged alcoholics. During her tenure, their numbers were swelled by very many teenagers who could no longer claim state benefits in often dire personal circumstances. It was a striking and visible change on the streets of British cities, and sat alongside the shameless wealth creation for the elite. It felt like the end of a compassionate state.
-
Was there through the Thatcher chapter. Nearly bought our council house for a price which the market would have quadrupled in the next five years – saved from a lifelong sense of guilt by an urgent return to an unrecognisable yet somehow familiar Rogernomical NZ (will we dance on his grave?). John Peel and Steve Bell helped keep us sane in those days.
[ [2116-22-7-04_REJOICE.jpeg] ] sorry not up to speed with posting images
Post your response…
This topic is closed.