Posts by richard

  • Speaker: Market failure in the research world, in reply to BenWilson,

    So long as researchers themselves personally value these exclusive journals so highly, this can not change. This can only get worse.

    It is easy to over-estimate the extent to which exclusive journals like Science and Nature drive this, as they represent a tiny fraction of all academic publication. Moreover, they are somewhat field dependent -- I have never tried to submit to either of them but I am doing ok, professionally. (Although I do try to get into Physical Review Letters when I have a suitably pithy and significant result, and have a reasonable strike rate with those attempts -- but I recognize that the process is bound to be somewhat random.)

    So to me the question is: Why do you value them so highly? Are they really providing you with value? I don’t just mean the value of being published in them, but the actual reading of them. Is their ability to pick out the good research from the bad really worth so much? Or is it quite literally their exclusivity that generates their value, almost in its entirety? That you can’t even get the research any other way?

    It’s bizarre to think of this kind of human pyramid existing. No wonder people don’t want to get into research. It’s not just the money, it’s the very idea that the quality of one’s work and ideas counts for so little compared to one’s access to the information channels, and all the kudos grafting involved.

    In my field, everything is essentially available on the "Archive" (arxiv.org) and it is the first place I look for any paper, even if it is published. Consequently, in terms of communicating with my colleagues or the general public I have no need to publish in peer-reviewed journals at all.

    In terms of broader science, I do tend to look at Nature, Science and Physical Review Letters for a sense of what is happening outside my field, and for better or worse, they do serve a useful role as "curators", albeit a someone circular one. Consequently, having exclusive venues (however that exclusivity is maintained) for publication probably serves a useful function. But I also find papers via Twitter :-)

    That said, I do set some store by publishing in decent journals -- which in my case is typically either Physical Review (which is a broad set of journals, run by the American Physical Society) and the Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics (and run by an Italian lab and the British IOP), which is narrower. Neither journal is "rationed" for space, and while crap papers slip though, peer review is nontrivial, and as someone else observed, the approbation of your peers can be a big part of an academic's job satisfaction.

    Both journals have decent "quality metrics" (impact factors or whatever alternative you prefer) so they undoubtedly help with research assessment exercises, getting my students jobs, and convincing funders I am returning value for money, but I don't think that is why I am publishing with them, rather than less demanding journals :-)

    It is easy to design "better" systems, but I think it is significant that the positive changes that have occurred around open access have typically delivered immediate benefits to the people participating in them, with little cost.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Hard News: 2014: The Meth Election,

    Don't bogart that election, Russell.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Hard News: Friday Music: Grey Fucking Area, in reply to Stephen Judd,

    If you pay a lot of money for an autographed Mein Kampf I damn well will think less of you. “Owning a book” is wilfully missing the point.

    (Snap). It isn't a smear when the guy rolled in the mud of his own volition.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Hard News: Friday Music: Grey Fucking Area,

    would anyone have summoned the Nazis had Dotcom not been, y’know, German?

    And owner of a signed copy of Mein Kampf.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Speaker: Let's talk about class,

    Pike River was on about the same scale as the recent disaster in Turkey, relative the size of our country -- people SHOULD be out in the streets about this. Or the slow motion disaster that is unfolding in our forests.

    Ironically, at the same time you can find any number of people complaining about namby-pamby health and safety rules that won't let you do anything, and yet it is so toothless that not only did 21 people die in a single "accident", but no-one is going to go to jail for it.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Speaker: Sponsored post: Speed and Safety, in reply to Matthew Poole,

    In terms of released energy, yes, it’s four times as bad thanks to the “squared” in the theory of relativity.

    Umm?

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Muse: Guilt By Association Copy, in reply to Russell Brown,

    I didn’t mean to imply that Dotcom has roomful of Nazi memorabilia. Nor would I necessarily judge someone for owning a copy of Mein Kampf. But to go out of your way to buy a copy whose main attraction is that it was personally handled by Hitler – I think you are entitled to think there’s something just a little bit sick about that.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Muse: Guilt By Association Copy,

    Someone's showing you round their house, and they open a door and say "Here's where I keep my copy of Mein Kampf that Hitler personally signed, along with my other Nazi memorabilia" -- yeah, I'd judge them.

    If you are arguing that this was germane to his legal problems, then I guess the answer is no -- but is it relevant when we are talking about someone who wants to bankroll a political party that may be able to influence the composition and policies of our next government? Then I think the answer is likely yes.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Hard News: The Internet Party, whatever happens,

    It's ironic, although the legal case against Dotcom has grown thinner with time, the enthusiasm with which I would greet his deportation (to anywhere, I'm not fussy) grows stronger with each passing day.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

  • Hard News: Cultural Heroes and living memory,

    Wow. This is quiet. Everyone must be reading twitter.

    Not looking for New Engla… • Since Nov 2006 • 260 posts Report Reply

Last ←Newer Page 1 2 3 4 5 26 Older→ First